So here are the contenders so far:
Little LambThis is probably my front-runner. Cute, cuddly, and cute. And it's a very similar setup to the costume she wore last year. I'm making us all dress up this year, so we'd need to figure out what to be to match her. I'm thinking farm animals? I could be Mary but I'm not sure what that would entail. I'd be a much better pig/cat/cow.
BatI know this one's not all cuddly, and it's all black which I'm not usually a fan of, but the expression on this kid's face was just too cute to not post.
Puffy OwlHow cute is this?! I have a feeling the wings would bug her though. And she'd probably pull the cape off altogether.
Watermelon or StrawberryI love these but think she would yank the little hat off in no time. But a whole family dressed like fruits is appealing. Ahhh this is just making me more and more indecisive as I go along...
ChickenI mean, why not continue in the duck vain by going poultry all the way? It's probably a boy's costume but I think it's so funnycute.
Horse RiderOK this one's not really a contender, but it cracked me up. I'm still laughing. It's kind of amazing.